AMERICAN IDOL is fast in danger of becoming a parody of itself. The judges have nobody but themselves to blame, either. How they let through so many of these contestants to this round of the competition is astonishing. With a couple of exceptions, they all sucked.
Ashley, the beautiful 17 year old, got slammed down so hard by EVERYONE (including Ryan Seacrest) that I wanted to give her the pity vote. Sheesh, there was nowhere for her to hide. When you’re told, “Sorry. Thanks for coming.” You’re in trouble. If it’s Paula saying that given your singing talents, you should consider acting — you’re in trouble. And when Ryan has nothing left to say after that, go home. I felt bad for her. The strange thing is, she started off OK. Not great, but not bad. But that song took her places that she should not have gone.
Aside from the Marine, Joshua Gracin, I didn’t care for any of them. Corey Clark was OK, but I wouldn’t have given him a standing ovation. Patrick Lake was my one hope for Rock N Roll, but he missed a couple of notes and his voice cracked a couple of times. Still, I’d vote for him to go through, just to bring some diversity to the competition that’s filled with warbling. (My god, even Steven Grant points it out in his column today.)
The really sad thing is that there are at least four contestants from the first two rounds who DESERVE to be in the Top Ten who didn’t make it, while there are at least 3 currently in the Top Ten who shouldn’t be, while two more will go through tonight (and most likely one won’t deserve it.) Now I’m just rambling.
One other thing: Shut up, shut up, shut up, you arrogant foolish children. It’s not cool to argue with the judges. We’re all sick of it. Juanita — you suck. Go home, you diva wannabe. Randy Jackson can sing better than you. The British have more teeth than you having singing ability, so stop picking on Simon.
Last night was a complete train wreck, saved only by USMC man.
I’ll go “out on a limb” and say that Josh and Corey will go through. They probably were the best of the overall pathetic night.
The wild card competition will be this show’s saving grace. Sadly, at least two will be left behind.