The show opened with a group singalong to Steve Miller Band’s “The Joker.” Stealers Wheel’s “Stuck in the Middle With You.” The contestants sang most often in groups of three. The producers put together LaKisha, Sabrina, and Sanjaya in one grouplet. Even the producers know that their best bet is to drown out Sanjaya as much as possible.
And so now we have it. The final 12. And it’s not without its controversies. Let’s start with the biggest one of all:
Antonella didn’t make it?!? How did that happen? The horny teenage boy demographic was not voting this week, I guess. I was shocked. Never let it be said that she didn’t maintain a sense of humor,though. Did you see the funny faces she made every time she missed a note? For the first time this season, I actually came to like her last night. Not that she deserved to make the final cut, mind you, but I liked the cut of her jib.
Sanjaya did make it! OK, but that was predictable. He was the lead vote getter a couple of weeks ago, and the confused female teenage demo votes huge for this show. It also brings up a great question: Is Sanjaya the weakest contestant ever to make the Final 12 in IDOL history? Is he worse than Kevin Covais? Camile Velasco? Ejay Day?
Jarrod got cut. At least I predicted one right. It was the only one, as it turned out, but that wasn’t all bad. After all, I predicted Jordin would get tossed, and she didn’t.
Sabrina got cut?!? That’s the biggest shock of the night, I think, and the first example of vote splitting we’re going to see this season. Fairly or not, she got lumped in with the other divas. And the others were just a little more over-the-top and memorable. Sabrina is a great singer, but she didn’t do quite enough to stick out from a very crowded field of like-sounding singers this year.
I also wonder if she didn’t get sunk by the judges’ comments. Contestants who are merely OK don’t get votes. Those that stink get the votes from their fans who want to save them. Those who do extremely well are remembered and get the votes for their amazing performances. Those in the middle — which is where Sabrina landed — don’t get enough votes. There is no such thing as “safe” on this show. And the judges liked her, but offered some constructive criticism without wildly singing her praises.
The way the show was put together, it appeared that Haley took Sabrina’s spot in the Final 12. I don’t think that’s at all fair. Ditto for the way Sanjaya appeared to take Sundance’s spot. That’s just the way they designed the show. Contestants were not eliminated in any particular order, remember, save for the highest possible melodrama.
If anything, Haley stole Antonella’s spot, and I’m fine with that. She’s a slightly better singer. (And I think she’s cuter, anyway. She’s a wannabe Child of the 80s.) And since her style is so different from the rest of the women in the Final 12, I think she benefited. If she was a weak diva, she’d have been done. Instead, she’s a slightly harmless middle-of-the-road not-quite-sure-what-she-wants-to-be singer. Is she country? Pop? Balladeer? I hope she figures that out quickly. Diana Ross might just eat her up next week, otherwise. But the point is, she stood out. She wasn’t LaKisha/Melinda/Stephanie/Sabrina. She was up against Antonella and, if you stretched it out a little bit, Gina. Gina got through because there were no other rock chicks this year. Haley got through because she’s a slightly better singer than Antonella.
It’s all about standing out.

Carrie sang last night. She has not, thankfully, undergone a Kellie Pickler-style transformation. Thank heaven for little favors.
Simon got the funniest line of night. At the end of the show when Ryan asked him why IDOL has the Top 12 that it has this year, Simon quipped, “The volume was turned down?”
Sundance’s “Somebody please give me a job!” plea gets the vote for second funniest line of the night.
Last night’s show was the 200th IDOL episode, and they’re celebrating this year by giving themselves the warm and fuzzies and donating lots of money to starving children in Africa and New Orleans (oh, and maybe someplace else in America, in case it gets trendy there, too.) There followed a long and painful Ryan and Simon feel good about themselves for going to Africa video. Everyone feels good, the audience tepidly applauds a really fun series deciding that it needs to be Important all of a sudden, and then Ryan announces the special episodes that will follow. The week of April 24th and 25th will be special. The final six contestants will sing inspirational songs. (LaKisha will blow the roof off the place with something, I’m sure.) Quincy Jones is writing a song for the results show. And there will be a whole host of special guests that night including Pink, Gwen Stefani, Michael Buble, Il Divo (Simon’s group), Bono (where there’s African charities, there’s Bono), and –
Borat.
Why do I even want to watch the train wreck now?
I’ll be back on Monday or Tuesday with my annual awful predictions for who will win, and in which order the contestants will fall.