It’s Latin week, and noted “singer” Jennifer Lopez came down from her block to act as dance coach to the contestants. Every now and then, she also told them to “feel” the song. Aside from that, she was completely useless.
The rest of the episode was a rehash of Gloria Estefan night, with some Carlos Santana thrown in for good measure. That’s a bit of an oversimplification, but not by much.
Sadly, it was not a memorable night for the show. The performances were not stellar. The best of them were just good. There was nothing great in the show, nothing memorable. Boring.
You knew it was going to be an off night when they led off with Melinda and LaKisha.
Melinda Doolittle sang “Sway Me,” which is a Latin classic of some sort. It was, indeed, a safe song. I don’t think she was nearly as sexy or as sultry as she was supposed to be for the song, but she made a good show of trying to be. Sometimes, I think those video packages really hurt the contestants, because they put one aspect of the performance in their minds, and everything else drops away. Even if everything else went spectacularly, the audience and the judges will focus mostly on what the mentor said in the package and forget the rest. Shame.
Her vocals were fine, though, and who doesn’t love Melinda? After Simon criticized her, she told Randy that she was happy she finally gave Simon the chance to say something bad about her. That cracked up both Randy and Simon. It also earned her the extra votes to stay out of the bottom three this week. That pole position is painful for contestants.
The only distracting thing about the song was that it reminded me so much of “Perhaps, Perhaps, Perhaps,” the theme song from Brit-Com COUPLING. I miss that show. . .
LaKisha went with “Conga.” All of a sudden, I thought I was at a bad wedding. This also started the parade of songs where the background singers and instruments took over the night, leaving the lead vocals in the dust. I give LaKisha credit for stretching a bit and not doing another ballad, but this was merely passable. The song isn’t a great choice. It doesn’t have great range and it feels very repetitive. She tried to dance, but she can’t. And by the end of the song, I thought she was starting to lose her wind. She’s not used to all that walking and singing, let alone dancing. Eh.
Chris Richardson went with “Smooth,” one of the most overplayed songs of the last decade. All I could think of the entire time he was up there was that Chris Daughtry would have rocked the song. Chris did a good job with it, though. He made it his own, although I think he tried too much to do so in a few spots. I didn’t like it, mind you, but that’s my personal preference. I could do without all the runs. I think enough people will like it and him — particularly after the boring first two singers — that he’ll skate on by another week.
Most importantly, he looked comfortable doing “his thing.” He didn’t look like he was just trying to get past the week, as so many contestants do with themes they just can’t hook into.
Haley Scarnato sang “Turn The Beat Around,” another classic anti-IDOL song. The background singers drowned her out so badly I couldn’t even tell she was singing half the time. Her hair and makeup proved such an ugly distraction that I couldn’t even watch it. What was with that bright red lipstick? Why did she pull her hair up like that? I understand the shorts: Simon hit it right on the head. I just don’t think I could have been as honest with her on national television, but good for Simon for calling it as he sees it. It wasn’t bad, but there was nothing there. In the end, the performance was what you’d expect — two long legs with a voice.
But she should shoot the hair and makeup people backstage.
More after the break:
(more…)