Call me terribly old-fashioned, but the first thing I tested out my new HDTV with was a DVD. I know, I know. That’s not true high definition. Heck, on a 1080p TV, a DVD is puny, weighing in at a fraction of the resolution. But with the help of an upconverting DVD player, it’s really a fun way to test a new TV using video you’re familiar with.
And, sure enough, the first thing I popped in was THE ROCK. I’ve always used that car chase scene as my demo disc. While it looked fine on the new TV, I was blown away when I skipped ahead a bit. Go to the scene where the military men — led by Goodspeed with the aid of Sean Connery — come out of the water and enter Alcatraz. It’s a relatively dark scene, with some bright flares of flaming light. It blew me away. The images were as clear as could be. The widescreen aspect ratio looked huge on the widescreen television set. It was as close to the movie theater experience at home as I’ve ever been able to muster.
What didn’t look nearly as good was the STAR WARS DVDs. I plunked in Episode 2 to check out a couple of scenes. I skipped straight to the action scene through the busy skyways of Coruscant. Everything was so crisp and clear that it looked like a cheap kiddy movie, filmed with actors looking silly in front of green screens. There was no separation between the two, and everything wound up looking like, well, a green-screened CGI movie. Sad, really.
I watched a couple of scenes from X-MEN 2, as well, which looked nice. As did KILL BILL Part One. Nothing overwhelming, but very nice.
Last night, we sat down to watch a complete movie. One of the things that should be in everyone’s home theater demo kit is a PIXAR movie. There’s magic in those images. Between the clear animation, the bright colors, and the subtle gradations, reflections, textures, etc., it gives your TV the chance to shine. While CARS is a moderately decent movie, suffering from being about a half hour longer than it really needed to be, it’s a great demo disc. It fills the screen up and has enough landscape shots to really wow you. There’s one shot of the open road about an hour and five minutes into the movie — just when Lightning briefly considers breaking for it after Sally filled up his gas tank — that I had to rewind back to. It’s such a beautiful shot that you could easily mistake it for reality. Every shadow, every shade, every texture works together beautifully. PIXAR spent some time on other large scale landscape angles, and they’re all worth a viewing. Take a look at the scene where Sally takes Lightning out for a drive. Just great to look at.
HDTV is a thing of beauty. By the time I had everything set up on Friday night, I was able to catch the Yankees game, which was on the west coast and so beautifully timed. I’ve seen high def golf and baseball and football before. Seeing it in your own home, though — it’s really cool. It took my eyes a couple of minutes to adjust to having everything looking that sharp — and, yes, I did turn down the sharpness a tad from the factory settings — but it all looked amazing after that.
I also laid eyes on TNT HD, National Geographic HD, Discovery HD, and the major networks. Beautiful stuff, all around, though there’s still a frustrating lack of HD content on the major networks outside of prime time. Even worse, all the good HD shows I’d like to watch don’t come back until January — LOST, 24, and AMERICAN IDOL. It’ll be a long wait.
On the sad side, TiVo looks like crap. Nothing you can do there. Just record everything at highest quality and hope for the best. In the meantime, I’ll record as much as possible on the HD DVR from the cable company. The interface sucks, but you can’t argue with the video quality. TiVo will work well for when three things are on at the same time, or for recording shows where video quality isn’t all that important.
Right now, I’m hoping the format war and the price points shake out in time for Christmas so I can push this TV with true high def DVD content.