I played seriously with Lightroom this weekend. It’s the relatively new photo organizing/editing tool from the folks who make Illustrator and Photoshop. It’s a direct competitor to Apple’s Aperture program. All reviews I’ve read say the two are pretty close. Aperture gets the edge in some places because it’s been around a little longer and that head start counts for something. It’s also a native Mac app, so it takes advantage of some built-in OS X design and functionality that a cross-platform release like Lightroom can’t.
I went with Lightroom in the end because it was only $200 when I bought it, as opposed to Aperture’s $299 price point. They’re both at $299 now.
I had to sit down with a book in order to understand how the program works, though. There’s just way too many buttons and panels and options to wrap my head around it completely on my own. I’m sure Aperture isn’t as complicated, but this is the road I picked.
The book I chose is Scott Kelby’s “The Adobe Photoshop Lightroom Book for Digital Photographers.” It’s an entertaining read, as Kelby cracks jokes constantly through the text. Sometimes it gets to be a bit much, but it kept my eye on the page, rather than the dry technical manuals so many other books explaining applications can be. If that kind of thing might annoy you, then do yourself a favor and avoid the introduction text - the “Unexpected Q&A Section” — like a plague. Stay far far away from it. It doesn’t tell you much; it’s more Kelby exercising his stand-up comedian muscles. it’s fine for what it is, but it’s mostly a waste of time if you’re a “serious student.”
The other problem with the book couldn’t be helped: Lightroom evolved during its development, from its major open beta release to the final shipping product. Some of the screen shots and options presented in the book aren’t there anymore, or are in slightly different places. Honestly, it looks like some decent options were stripped away between the Beta and the final product, but I’m sure Adobe had a reason for that.
When you get to the meat of the program, though, it’s exactly what I was looking for. The front half of the book gave me an overview of how to import photos into Lightroom in a very useful way, including metadata, filenames, organization, keywords, the works. It shows you different ways you can look through the files, organize them into folder and categories, search via keywords, etc. Most usefully, it taught me how to use keywords. My first attempts at those were dismal failures, where I would end up with the same keywords on all pictures, whether they deserved them or not.
The real revelation to my digital photo handling, though, came in the next part of the book, which is a brief demonstration of how to use Lightroom’s basic photo editing options to clean up pictures. I didn’t realize just how blue or dark my photos looked until the book showed me the “Auto” setting on “White Balance.” After that, some basic introductions to the histogram, recovery options, contrast, and more helped me create photos that jumped off the screen instead of just sitting there. They didn’t look like pictures anymore — they looked like grabs of real life images. I was impressed. And, thankfully, Kelby shows you how to apply those same changes across multiple pictures, which is really handy when editing a sequence of files.
Lightroom makes all of this fairly easy to control and remember once you learn the process. The key commands are obvious — “G” for grid view, “L” for loupe view, for two quick examples — and the options are presented along the left and right columns in a way that’s both easy to find and easy to hide.
The funny thing is that I’m not even halfway through the book yet. I have to delve into advanced photo editing features next, in which I’ll no doubt learn why an “S” shaped tone curve is the best option. Everything after that is probably not all that necessary for me, though. I probably won’t be using Lightroom to create slide shows or web presentations. It’s nice to know that’s there, though, should I need them in the future.
Since Lightroom makes all of these changes to the photo in a way that’s completely reversible at any time, I can learn as I go and not damage the original pictures along the way. This makes it a lot easier to experiment, learn, and grow.
Next step: Import the other 5000 pictures over from iPhoto into Lightroom. The book explains how to do that, but it’s a “big step” I wanted to make sure I was prepared for before starting it. That’s a big commitment.
Once more into the breach — !!!